Showing tremendous balance across its 23 varsity intercollegiate athletics teams and enjoying consistent success throughout the years,  Wittenberg’s athletics program emerged victorious in the race for the 2009-10 North Coast Athletic Conference (NCAC) All-Sports championship. Tiger teams won or shared 2009-10 regular season championships in field hockey, football, volleyball, women’s basketball, men’s golf and men’s lacrosse to go along with a total of 18 top-five finishes in the 22 NCAC championship sports.

Wittenberg is the only one of the four schools to win the All-Sports trophy that was not a charter member of the NCAC, which started competition in 1984.